What is the name of a review guide that compiles consumer comments instead of relying solely on food critics?

The correct answer is the Zagat Survey, which is known for compiling consumer reviews and ratings rather than relying predominantly on professional food critics. This approach emphasizes the collective opinions of everyday patrons, allowing a broader range of experiences and preferences to be represented. The Zagat Survey organizes feedback from real customers about various aspects of a dining experience, such as food quality, service, and ambiance, which helps potential diners make informed choices based on a diverse array of perspectives.

Yelp, while also a platform for consumer reviews, is not the specific answer being sought in this context, as it operates differently from the structured compilation seen in the Zagat Survey. The Michelin Guide is primarily known for its star rating system awarded by professional critics and does not focus on consumer comments. TripAdvisor shares user-generated reviews but operates in a broader travel context, extending beyond just dining establishments. Therefore, the Zagat Survey stands out as the appropriate reference for a guide that specifically curates consumer insights for restaurants.